A few days after we paired five watering valves, one of them went quiet. It had been unreachable since a quarter past one in the morning, and its first watering run ever was due that night.
The first guess, and why it was wrong
The valve was off the network, so the obvious reading was that it had fallen off the mesh: too far from a router, a weak signal, move it. That reading is the shape of the evidence, not a cause.
The person who owns the house pushed back: “it’s got good signal there.”
They were right.
What the device list showed
Zigbee is a mesh. Battery devices like the valves are end devices. They do not carry anyone else’s traffic. Each one attaches to a mains-powered router, its parent, and talks through it. The list of devices says which parent each one is using.
Reading it, the valve was the only end device in the house with no parent router at all.
Two mains-powered routers, small plugs, had gone silent the day before and were still down. The valve’s old parent was one of them. Its sibling valve, the one at the sink, had the same dead parent, and it was fine. It had a second parent to go to.
A device with good signal and no parent is not out of range. It is an orphan.
The signal was there. The valve had simply not re-attached.
The proof
A healthy router sat at the back porch with link quality of 152, where higher is better. After the valve was reconnected, its link quality read 168, stronger than every other valve but one. Same place, same valve. The only thing that changed was that it had a parent again.
Two other things that night
- The battery said 100 percent, as it does on every valve. It had never read anything else, so it said nothing here either. A number that cannot change cannot warn you.
- The fault was in the mesh, not in the valve. Replacing the valve would have changed nothing.
What we filed, not fixed
- The two dead plugs, which are the actual hole in the mesh.
- Three of the four working valves hung off a single router, with no second parent, the same shape that had just failed once.
- The audit that would have shown this. It ran only when somebody ran it by hand, because the service meant to run it unattended had never been started.
What to take from it
- A mesh is only as strong as its routers. Small plugs are routers, so a dead plug can be a hole in the network.
- When a battery device drops off, look at its parent before you look at its signal.
- Give important devices a second way in. A valve that needs to run at night should not hang on a single plug.
- Do not trust a battery number that has never moved.
The valve is one of five in this house. The page about the valves has what each one reports.