For the curious: you do not need any of this to set a temperature.
Back to devices.
At a glance
| Item | Nest Thermostat E (2017) | ecobee Smart Thermostat Premium |
|---|---|---|
| Zone | One house | A second unit |
| Path to Home Assistant | Google’s cloud, about five commands a minute | Local, over HomeKit |
| Matter | Not capable | Not needed |
| Reports | Temperature, humidity, running state, eco preset, fan on or off | Temperature, humidity, running state, fan, a button to clear a hold, occupancy and motion, one remote sensor |
| Keeps to itself | Aux heat | Aux heat |
The one we nearly changed
We planned to replace both with Matter thermostats, one per zone. We bought them and never installed them. After looking at what they would buy, we kept what we had and returned the new ones. They would have given local control of the main house only, with nothing on aux heat, fan, holds or schedules, and would have cost the second unit its remote sensor and its occupancy. The lesson: check what you would lose before swapping something that works.
Off and On
Two buttons, not one toggle. Off turns both thermostats off. On brings each thermostat that is off back to its own last mode and its own last setpoint, a single temperature or a low and high pair. One already on is left alone, and one with nothing remembered stays off and says so. The memory is written from the thermostats’ own state, so a change on the dial or in the maker’s app is remembered the same as one made here.
Open up, close up
The house can tell you once when to open the windows and once when to close up. It never touches a window and never changes a thermostat unless you tap the button in the notification.
The rule, in plain words:
- It wants cooling when inside is at or above 77; heat when it is under 68 with the thermostat off.
- Outside has to be cooler than inside, or falling at least a degree an hour and on track to cross inside within an hour.
- Humid outside air is allowed a little more room, using dew point and not relative humidity, because relative humidity rises as a room cools.
- It closes up when outside has stopped falling for 30 minutes, or when the night gets near the 50 floor.
Each number is a setting. The advice sits on a short list, not just in a notification, so you can ask “what is the house suggesting?”
The honest limit: it cannot see a window. “Close up” stays on the list until someone ticks it or the next “open up” replaces it, and the sentence under it is what was true when it was written.
Ask your assistant
How long did the heat pump run on the hottest afternoons, and how warm was it outside?
Your assistant reads the running state against the outdoor temperature, run by run.