Ask three houses whether anyone is in the kitchen and you get three kinds of answer. One has a sensor made for it. One has a light somebody switched on. One has a phone that says someone is home. They are not equally sure, and a good answer says which one it used.
So every thing a house can be asked for has a ladder: the ways to know it, best first. Each rung says what it gets wrong, in plain words, and what it costs to climb.
Five ways to know someone is in a room
| Rung | How | What it gets wrong | Rough cost |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | A millimetre-wave presence sensor | Trips on a ceiling fan, a space heater’s rising air or a cat. A very still person still registers, so it over-counts, not under-counts | About $30 to $80 |
| 2 | A motion sensor (PIR) | Detects movement, not presence. Someone reading, on a call or asleep goes dark after the sensor’s timeout and the room reads empty | About $15, often already installed |
| 3 | Device activity: a light switched by hand, a TV playing, a phone on this access point | Says someone was there recently, not that they are. A TV playing to an empty room reads as occupied | Free |
| 4 | A door contact and arithmetic | Counts people through one door. Wrong as soon as two people are involved, and wrong from the start if there is a second way in | About $12 a door |
| 5 | The phone’s location | Whole house only, useless for a single room. Undercounts anyone whose phone lost its connection or location permission | Free |
The costs are estimates, not checked against current listings. The top two need a Zigbee, Z-Wave or Thread radio paired to Home Assistant first, which is a separate purchase.
Presence is also the one signal that Life Lever Home does not send to your record. This ladder is here because it is the clearest way to see the idea.
It is the same for other things
Power draw
Best: a metering plug or a clamp on the circuit. Next: the appliance's own report. A strip behind one plug reports the whole strip. A manufacturer's cloud outage can freeze the last reading with nothing saying it is stale.
Soil moisture
Best: a probe. Next: a controller's estimate from weather data. A probe reads a few inches around its tip. An estimate is calculated, so a shaded bed or a bed against a hot wall can be wrong in the same direction all season.
A water leak
Best: a point sensor, but it sees only the spot where it sits. Next: a whole-home flow monitor, which cannot say which fixture and can miss a slow drip. A valve's own flow meter sees flow while shut, and nothing while open.
An appliance running
Best: the appliance's own cycle state, which can go stale in an outage. Next: a power threshold from a plug, which tells drawing from not drawing and not which part of the cycle.
Room temperature
Best: a sensor placed where you are. Next: the thermostat's own, in a hallway or a return-air path, often not where a person is. Some devices report an internal chip temperature that looks like a room reading and is not.
A utility meter
Best: the utility's or inverter's own feed, where one exists. Next: a total worked out from generation and load sensors, which drifts quietly if any one of them does.
What changes when you know the rung
- Your assistant can say it. “That is estimated from whole-house load” is a different answer from “that is the heater’s draw.”
- The upgrade has a price. When a house is on a lower rung, the answer can name the rung above and what it costs, so you decide whether an exact number is worth a purchase.
- Nothing is passed off. A number worked out from other numbers is labelled as worked out.
The water heater is the example we care about. Usually it has no meter of its own, so its draw during a shower starts as whole-house load minus what is metered. That is a derived number, and the answer says so. A heater is usually on its own 240-volt circuit, so the next rung is a meter on that circuit; we have not checked which applies to ours.
When the same evidence fits two things
A switch with no label could be a dedicated relay, a heater’s on and off control or an irrigation valve. Nothing in the list of devices says which. Life Lever Home does not pick quietly. It reports the better rung where it found a match and names every other reading the same evidence fits. Which one it is gets settled in a conversation with you, once, and again whenever something new appears.
Where this stands
The ladders
About three dozen signals, each with its ladder, kept as plain data. Adding a signal or a rung is a change to a file.
The rung in your record
An answer says which rung it rests on, so you know how far to trust it.
Back to Home.